Recolonization origin and reproductive locations, but not isolation from the sea, lead to genetic structure in migratory lagoonal fishes

Abstract

The assessment of connectivity in marine ecosystems is a requirement to adequate fisheries management. In this study we have selected two commercially exploited migratory species, European perch (Perca fluviatilis) and European smelt (Osmerus eperlanus), to evaluate the connectivity between the Curonian Lagoon and the coastal Baltic Sea. Our results indicate that isolation between the coastal lagoon and the adjacent sea area does not lead to the formation of genetic structure in migratory fish species. However, both species do register subpopulations coexisting in the area without interbreeding. This indicates that the fisheries management for migratory fishes in coastal lagoons affects a wider area than just the coastal lagoon. European perch, being a postglacial recolonizer from various refugees, has four different subpopulations, while the mechanism that maintains this division remains unexplored. The feeding migrations of European perch to the coastal zone suggest that the reproduction might occur elsewhere and that the factors for genetic structure suggested at the Baltic Sea scale might operate during these migrations. For European smelt, we discuss the existence of two different ecotypes, one lagoonal and one diadromous, and the different registered spawning locations as explicative causes for the maintenance of two genetically divergent clusters. The lagoonal ecotype reproduces and spawns inside the Curonian Lagoon while the diadromous one lives in the open Baltic Sea, performing spawning migrations to the lagoon and the mouth of Nemunas river, thus, maintaining the genetic divergence among them. However, our results indicate that there are no differences in size between both clusters, while the lagoonal population is expected to be smaller, forbidding the determination of two genetically different ecotypes. We conclude that there are no geographically and genetically separated populations of these two species in the lagoon-sea- terrestrial inlets continuum, and unified stock management for the coastal Baltic Sea and the Curonian lagoon is required.