Publication: Does the pension system’s income statement really matter? A proposal for an NDC scheme with disability and minimum pension benefits
Full text at PDC
Advisors (or tutors)
Fac. de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales > Instituto Complutense de Análisis Económico
This paper develops a full accounting model for monitoring the solvency of a notional defined contribution (NDC) pension scheme with disability and minimum pension benefits. Using the annual report of the Swedish pension system as a benchmark (TSPS, 2018), we extend the “Swedish” actuarial balance developed by Pérez-Salamero et al. (2017) by adding an income statement which fully explains the reasons behind the changes in the system’s solvency by type of benefit. In line with the reference model, assets and liabilities are measured at present value at each reporting date, and changes in present value are reported in each period as income or expenses and are included on the income statement. Our proposed model is a step forward because it, also, incorporates the changes for disability pensions, the value of change in the discount rate and the explicit recognition of non-contributory rights (NCRs) into the Income statement. This accounting framework integrates both contributory and social aspects of public pensions and discloses the real cost of the disability contingency and the redistribution through minimum pensions. The paper contains a numerical example consisting of an income statement for a (fictional) already-functioning system to illustrate the main differences between the Swedish NDC scheme and our model. Mathematical details are presented in a comprehensive technical appendix.
REFERENCES AAA (American Academy of Actuaries). (1998). “Actuarial Standard of Practice No. 32, Social Insurance” Committee on Social Insurance of the American Academy of Actuaries. AAD (Actuarial Affairs Division). (2017). “Summaries of the 2014 Actuarial Valuation and Reform Options.” Pension Bureau, Ministry of Health, Labour, and Welfare, Tokyo. Alonso-García, J. and P. Devolder (2019). Continuous time model for notional defined contribution pension schemes: Liquidity and solvency. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.insmatheco.2019.06.001. Armour, P. (2018). The Role of Information in Disability Insurance Application: An Analysis of the Social Security Statement Phase-In. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 10 (3): 1-41. Arnold, S., Jijiie, A., Jondeau, E. and Rockinger, M. (2019). Periodic or generational actuarial tables: which one to choose? European Actuarial Journal. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13385-019-00198-x. Arnold-Gaille, S., Boado-Penas, M.C. and H. Godinez-Olivares. (2016). Longevity Risk in Notional Defined Contribution Pension Schemes: A Solution. Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice. 41(1): 24-52. Arthur, W.B. and McNicoll, G. (1978) Samuelson, population and intergenerational transfers, International Economic Review. 19(1): 241-246. Autor, D., and M. C. Duggan. (2006). The Growth in the Social Security Disability Rolls: A Fiscal Crisis Unfolding. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 20(3): 71–96. AWG (2018a), Ageing Working Group. Polish country fiche on pension projections 2018. https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/economy-finance/2018-ageing-report-economic-and-budgetary-projections-eu-member-states-2016-2070_en . AWG (2018b), Ageing Working Group. Italy country fiche on pension projections 2018. https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/economy-finance/2018-ageing-report-economic-and-budgetary-projections-eu-member-states-2016-2070_en . Belloni, M. and C. Maccheroni (2013). Actuarial Fairness When Longevity Increases: An Evaluation of the Italian Pension System, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance: Issues and Practice. 38(4): 638–674. Benítez-Silva, H., R. Disney, and S. Jiménez-Martín. (2010). Disability, Capacity for Work, and the Business Cycle: An International Perspective. Economic Policy. 25(63): 483–536. Billig, A. and J.C. Ménard. (2013). Actuarial balance sheets as a tool to assess the sustainability of social security pension systems. International Social Security Review, 66(2): 31-62. Billig, A.; and J-C Ménard (2018). Measuring and reporting the actuarial obligations of the Canada Pension Plan. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 49-71. Billig, A.; S. Brimblecombe and J-C Ménard (2018). Introduction: Quantifying and reporting social security obligations. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 5-11. Blomberg, R. (2013), “Who Is Granted Disability Benefit in Sweden? Description of Risk Factors and the Effect of the 2008 Law Reform.” Master’s thesis in Mathematical Statistics, Royal Institute of Technology, School of Engineering Sciences, Stockholm, Sweden. Boado-Penas, M.C. and C. Vidal-Meliá. (2013). “The Actuarial Balance of the Pay-As-You-Go Pension System: The Swedish NDC model versus the US DB model.” In Holzmann, R., Palmer, E. and D. Robalino, eds., NDC Pension Schemes in a Changing Pension World, Chapter 14, Volume 2. Washington, DC: World Bank. Boado-Penas, M.C. and C. Vidal-Meliá. (2014). Nonfinancial defined contribution pension schemes: is a survivor dividend necessary to make the system balanced? Applied Economics Letters, 21(4): 242-247. Boado-Penas, M.C., Valdés-Prieto, S. and C. Vidal-Meliá. (2008). An Actuarial Balance Sheet for Pay-As-You-Go Finance: Solvency Indicators for Spain and Sweden, Fiscal Studies, 29(1): 89-134. Board of Trustees, Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Disability Insurance Trust Funds (BOT). (2018). 20187 Annual Report. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing. Borghans, L., A. C. Gielen, and E. F.P. Luttmer. (2014). Social Support Substitution and the Earnings Rebound: Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity in Disability Insurance Reform. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 6(4):1–39. Buchholtz, S., A Chłon-Dominczak, and M. Góra. (2019). The Polish NDC Scheme: Success in the Face of Adversity. (SOCIAL PROTECTION & JOBS Discussion Paper; 1902). The World Bank. Canadian Institute of Actuaries (CIA). (2017). “Social security programs”, in Standards of Practice. Ottawa, Canadian Institute of Actuaries. Cavanagh, J., S. Flynn and D. Moretti. (2016), Implementing Accrual Accounting in the Public Sector. Fiscal Affairs Department, IMF, Technical notes and manuals. Chen, G. and D.S. Matkin. (2017). Actuarial inputs and the valuation of public pension liabilities and contribution requirements: a simulation approach. Public Budgeting and Finance, 37(1): 68–87. Chłoń-Domińczak, A. and P. Strzelecki (2013), The minimum pension as an instrument of poverty protection in the defined contribution pension system – an example of Poland, Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 12(30): 326-350. CRS (2018). Trends in Social Security Disability Insurance Enrollment. Congressional Research Service. https://crsreports.congress.gov D’Ambrogi-Ola, B.; and R. L. Brown. (2018). Measuring and reporting obligations of social security retirement systems: Actuarial perspectives. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 13-25. Dabbicco, G. (2015). The Impact of Accrual-Based Public Accounting Harmonization on EU Macroeconomic Surveillance and Governments’ Policy Decision-Making. International Journal of Public Administration, 38 (4): 253-267. De Haan, J., Janssen, K., & Ponds, E. H. M. (2012). The Holistic Balance Sheet as the New Framework for European Pension Supervision - Evaluation from a Dutch Perspective. (Netspar Discussion Paper; Vol. 10/2012-033). Tilburg: NETSPAR. De Vries, G. (2010). Pension accounting standards. ECB/Eurostat e-book of the Workshop on Pensions, 55–78. Drouin, A., P. Plamondon and C. Lloret (2018). Towards a fair assessment of social security liabilities under pay-as-you-go and partially funded schemes. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 81-103. Duran, X., Vanroelend, C., Deboosere, P., & Benavides, F.G. (2016). Social security status and mortality in Belgian and Spanish male workers. Gaceta Sanitaria, 30(4): 293–295. EC (2018). The 2018 ageing report: Economic and budgetary projections for the 28 EU Member States (2016–2070) (European economy institutional paper, No. 079). Luxembourg, Publications Office of the European Union. EC et al. (2009). System of national accounts 2008. Brussels, European Commission, International Monetary Fund, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, United Nations, World Bank. Edwards, G., Martinez, G. and Contreras, J.P. (2015). “An Empirical Analysis of Possible Reforms to the Disability and Survivors Insurance in Chile.” Journal of Population Ageing, 8(4): 279-302. Eurostat (2010). European system of accounts ESA 2010. Luxembourg. Eurostat. (2011). Technical compilation guide for pension data in national accounts (Eurostat methodologies and working papers). Luxembourg, Eurostat, European Central Bank. Foote, A., M. Grosz, and S. Rennane. (2019). The Effect of Lower Transaction Costs on SSDI Application Rates and Participation. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 38: 99-123. Fredriksen, D. and Stølen, N.M. (2015), “Life Time Pension Benefits Relative to Life Time Contributions”, Discussion Paper No 825, Statistics Norway. Fredriksen, D., Holmøy, E., Strøm, B., & Stølen, N. (2019). Fiscal effects of the Norwegian pension reform – A micro–macro assessment. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 18(1): 88-123. García-Gómez P., Gielen A.C. (2018). Mortality effects of containing moral hazard: Evidence from disability insurance reform. Health Economics. 27(3): 606-621. Gjesdal, S., Svedberg, P., Hagberg, J., & Alexanderson, K. (2009). Mortality among disability pensioners in Norway and Sweden 1990—96: Comparative prospective cohort study. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 37(2): 168–175. Golosov, M., and Tsyvinski, A., (2016). Designing Optimal Disability Insurance: A Case for Asset Testing. Journal of Political Economy. 114 (2): 257– 79. Halvorsen, E. and Pedersen, A.W. (2019), Closing the gender gap in pensions: A microsimulation analysis of the Norwegian NDC pension system, Journal of European Social Policy, 29(1): 130– 143. Holzmann, R., Palacios, R. and A. Zviniene. (2001). On the economics and scope of implicit pension debt: an international perspective. Empirica, 28(1): 97–129. IAA. (2013). International standard of actuarial practice 2: Financial analysis of social security programs (ISAP 2). Ottawa, International Actuarial Association. IAA. (2018). Measuring and reporting actuarial obligations of social systems. Ottawa, International Actuarial Association – Social Security Committee. IMF. (2014). Government finance statistics manual 2014. Washington, DC, International Monetary Fund. IPSASB. (2017a). “IPSAS 1: Presentation of Financial Statements”, in Handbook of international public sector accounting pronouncements 2017: Vol. 1. New York, NY, International Federation of Accountants – International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board. IPSASB. (2017b). “Recommended Practice Guideline 1: Reporting on the long-term sustainability of an entity’s finances”, in Handbook of international public sector accounting pronouncements 2017: Vol. 2. New York, NY, International Federation of Accountants – International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board. IPSASB. (2017c). “The Conceptual Framework for General Purpose Financial Reporting by Public Sector Entities”, in Handbook of international public sector accounting pronouncements 2017: Vol. 1. New York, NY, International Federation of Accountants – International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board. IPSASB. (2019). Proposed International Public Sector Accounting Standard®: Social Benefits (IPSAS-42). New York, NY, International Federation of Accountants –International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board. ISSA (2018), Social Security Programs Throughout the World. Social Security Administration (SSA) and the International Social Security Association (ISSA). http://www.socialsecurity.gov/policy. ISSA; ILO. (2016). ISSA-ILO Guidelines on actuarial work for social security. Geneva. Jabłonowski, J. and C. Freudenberg (born Müller) (2014), A long-term assessment of the Polish disability fund and its possible reform. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329754032_A_LONG-TERM_ASSESSMENT_OF_THE_POLISH_DISABILITY_FUND_AND_ITS_POSSIBLE_REFORM. Jönsson, L., Palme, M. and Svensson, I. (2012), ‘Disability insurance, population health and employment in Sweden’, in Wise, D. A. (ed.), Social Security Programs and Retirement around the World: Historical Trends in Mortality and Health, Employment, and Disability Insurance Participation and Reforms, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Kaier, K. and C. Müller. (2015). New figures on unfunded public pensions entitlements across Europe: Concept, results and applications. Empirica, 42(4): 865–895. Knell, M. (2018). Increasing life expectancy and NDC pension systems. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 17(2): 170-199. Lassila, J.; Valkonen, T. (2008), Applying The Swedish Pension Brake. Helsinki: ETLA, Elinkeinoelämän Tutkimuslaitos, The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy, No. 1127). Li. Y. (2018). Paradoxical effects of increasing the normal retirement age: a prospective evaluation. European Economic Review, 101, 512-527. Lindner, S. (2016). How do unemployment insurance benefits affect the decision to apply for social security disability insurance? Journal of Human Resources, 51, 62–94. Low, H., and Pistaferri, L., (2015). Disability Insurance and the Dynamics of the Incentive‐Insurance Tradeoff. American Economic Review. 105, 2986– 3029. Mason, P. (2018). Accounting for social benefits: The search for a past event. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 73-80. Melis, R. and Trudda A. (2012). Financial and demographic risks impact on a pay-as-you-go pension fund. Economics Bulletin, 32(2): 1320-1329. Metzger, C. (2018). An actuarial balance sheet of the Swiss old-age pension scheme. International Social Security Review, 71(1): 25-49. Metzger, C. (2019). The German statutory pension scheme: Balance Sheet, Cross-sectional Internal Rates of Return and Implicit Tax Rates. Fiscal Studies. In press. Michaud, A., Nelson, J., Wiczer, D., (2018). Vocational Considerations and Trends in Social Security Disability, The Journal of the Economics of Ageing, 11, 41-51. OECD (2018), OECD Reviews of Pension Systems: Latvia, OECD Publishing, Paris. http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264289390-en . OECD (2019), Public spending on incapacity (indicator). doi: 10.1787/f35b71ed-en (Accessed on 20 May 2019). OSFIC. (2015). Canada Pension Plan Retirement, Survivor and Disability Beneficiaries Mortality Study (Actuarial study, No. 16). Ottawa, Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions – Office of the Chief Actuary. OSFIC. (2018). Measuring and reporting actuarial obligations of the Canada Pension Plan (Actuarial study, No. 19). Ottawa, Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions – Office of the Chief Actuary. Palmer, E. and B. Könberg (2019). The Swedish NDC Scheme: Success on Track with Room for Reflection. (SOCIAL PROTECTION & JOBS Discussion Paper; 1901). The World Bank. Park, J-M., Ukchan, O., Beop-Rae, R. & Yeongmin, M., (2017). Disparities in mortality by disability: an 11-year follow-up study of 1 million individuals. International Journal of Public Health, 62, 969-996. Pérez-Salamero González, J.M., Ventura-Marco, M. and C. Vidal-Meliá. (2017). A 'Swedish' Actuarial Balance Sheet for a Notional Defined Contribution Pension Scheme with Disability and Minimum Pension Benefits. International Social Security Review, 70 (3): 79-104. Phaup, M. (2019). Budgeting for Mandatory Spending: Prologue to Reform. Public Budgeting and Finance, 39(1): 24-44. Pitacco, E. (2014). Health Insurance. Basic Actuarial Models. EAA Series. Heidelberg. Plamondon, P., A. Drounin, G. Binet, M. Cichon, W. McGillivray, M. Bédard, and H. Pérez-Montas. (2002). Actuarial Practice in Social Security. Quantitative Methods in Social Protection Series. Geneva: International Social Security Association and International Labour Office. Qi, h., J. Helgertz, T. Bengtsson (2018). Do notional defined contribution schemes prolong working life? Evidence from the 1994 Swedish pension reform. The Journal of the Economics of Ageing, 12, 250-267. Rashbrooke, G. (2008). Exploration of application of actuarial Accounting methodology to the New Zealand flat rate social security pension. Presented at a joint Colloquium of the IACA, PBSS and IAAHS Sections, Boston, U.S.A. 4-7 May 2008. Regúlez-Castillo, M. and C. Vidal-Meliá (2012). Individual information for pension contributors: Recommendations for Spain based on international experience, International Social Security Review, 65(2): 1-27. Settergren, O. (2013). “A Decade of Actuarial Accounting for the NDC Scheme in Sweden: Quantifying Change in the Financial Position of a PAYG Pension Plan”. In Holzmann, R., Palmer, E. and D. Robalino, eds. NDC Pension Schemes in a Changing Pension World, Chapter 21, Volume 2. Washington, DC: World Bank Settergren, O. and B.D. Mikula. (2005). The rate of return of pay-as-you-go pension systems: a more exact consumption-loan model of interest. Journal of Pensions Economics and Finance, 4(2): 115-138. Society of Actuaries (SOA). 2014. RP-2014 Mortality Table Report Released in October 2014. Stavrakis, C. (2018). Reporting the pension obligations of social security schemes: An EU perspective. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 105-123. Sundén, A. (2012). “The challenge of reaching participants with the message of NDC”, in R. Holzmann, E. Palmer and D. Robalino (eds), Nonfinancial defined contribution pension schemes in a changing pension world: Vol. 2: Gender, politics, and financial stability. Washington, DC, World Bank. pp. 257-272 (Chapter 17). Takayama, N. (2005). Social Security Pensions in Japan: A Balance Sheet Approach. The Economic and Labour Relations Review, 15(2): 263-283. The Swedish Pension System. Orange Annual Report 2001. (TSPS) (2002). Ed. Ole Settergren. The National Social Insurance Board (Riksförsäkringsverket, RFV), Stockholm. The Swedish Pension System. Orange Annual Report 2017. (TSPS) (2018). Ed. Ole Settergren. Swedish Pensions Agency (Pensionsmyndigheten), Stockholm. Venti, S., Wise, D. A. (2015). The long reach of education: Early retirement. The Journal of the Economics of Ageing, 6, 133–148. Ventura-Marco, M. and C. Vidal-Meliá. (2014). An Actuarial Balance Sheet Model for Defined Benefit Pay-As-You-Go Pension Systems with Disability and Retirement Contingencies. Astin Bulletin, 44(2): 367-415. Ventura-Marco, M. and C. Vidal-Meliá. (2016). Integrating retirement and permanent disability in NDC pension schemes. Applied Economics, 48(12): 1081-1102. Vidal-Meliá, C. (2014). An assessment of the 2011 Spanish pension reform using the Swedish system as a benchmark. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance. 13(3): 297-333. Vidal-Meliá, C. and M.C. Boado-Penas. (2013). Compiling the actuarial balance for pay-as-you-go pension systems. Is it better to use the hidden asset or the contribution asset? Applied Economics, 45(10): 1303-1320. Vidal-Meliá, C., Boado-Penas, M.C. and F. Navarro-Cabo. (2016). Notional defined contribution pension schemes: why does only Sweden distribute the survivor dividend? Journal of Economic Policy Reform, 19(3): 200-220. Vidal-Meliá, C., Boado-Penas, M.C. and O. Settergren (2010). Instruments for improving the equity, transparency and solvency of PAYG pension systems. NDCs, ABs and ABMs. In Micocci, M., Gregoriou, G.N. and G. B. Masala (Eds.), Pension fund risk management, pp.419–473, Financial and actuarial modelling, New York: Chapman and Hall. chapter 18, ISBN 1439817520. Vidal-Meliá, C., Boado-Penas, M.C. and O. Settergren. (2009). Automatic balance mechanisms in pay-as-you-go pension systems. Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice, 34(2): 287–317. Vidal-Meliá, C., Ventura-Marco, M. and Pérez-Salamero González, J.M. (2018). “Social insurance accounting for a notional defined contribution scheme combining retirement and long-term care benefits.” Sustainability, 10, 2832. Wiener, M.; Stokoe, P. (2018). Discussing accrued-to-date liabilities. International Social Security Review, 71(3): 27-48. Wiese, P. (2006), “Financing Disability Benefits in a System of Individual Accounts: Lessons from International Experience”, Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, WP 2006-4. Willis, R. (1988). Life cycles, institutions and population growth: A theory of the equilibrium interest rate in an overlapping-generations model. pp. 106-138 in R.D. Lee, W.B. Arthur, & G. Rodgers, eds., Economics of Changing Age Distributions in Developed Countries. Oxford: Clarendon Press. ZUS (2017), Social Security in Poland, ZUS, Warsaw.